Misunderstood Functional GI Disorders: Gymnast’s Case Shows Why We Must Accept FGIDs as a Chronic Disorder

The New York Times Magazine recently posted a case report of a 15-year old world class gymnast who mysteriously developed abdominal cramps, diarrhea, constipation, and an inexplicable swelling (distension) of her abdomen. Numerous diagnostic tests, including MRIs and ultrasounds, and trips to a half dozen hospitals, including the Mayo Clinic, left gastroenterologists, neurologists, urologists, psychiatrists, surgeons, physical therapists, an endocrinologist, and a cardiologist scratching their heads in wonder. No one understood why the girl looked pregnant or why she couldn’t go to the bathroom without laxatives. When the tests kept coming back negative the doctors began to suspect that, "there was nothing really wrong: it was in her head." The girl was placed on numerous treatments without benefit including hypnosis, acupuncture, Chinese herbals, and prescription medications.

In the end, one pediatric gastroenterologist came to the conclusion that she must have a functional gastrointestinal disorder (FGID). More specifically she had irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) that was associated with a not uncommon condition (to those with a specialty in FGIDs) known as abdominal-phrenic dyssynergia. With this condition abdominal muscles relax when they should contract and the diaphragm contracts when it should relax, leading to distension. This is not an increase of gas or fluid in the abdomen; it’s a pushing out of the abdominal wall that can come and go during the day depending on meals, the degree of pain, stress levels, and other factors involving body functions. In addition, her constipation was due to incomplete relaxation of the pelvic floor muscles called pelvic floor dyssynergia, which responded to biofeedback treatment.

I am fascinated by this article, not because we are dealing with "mystery diagnoses" (we see a large number of patients with similar abdominal distension and dozens of patients with pelvic floor dyssynergia in our practice each year). What interests me is the high level of public interest that leads this case to be featured in the New York Times. What is it that renders so much attention? And what are the problems with this kind of attention? There are several factors we should consider:

  • The diagnosis of a functional GI disorder was made after many expensive and unneeded tests were performed, and by exclusion. IBS and other functional GI disorders are positive diagnoses. To recognize and accept these conditions as real will lead to fewer unneeded studies to "exclude organic disease." The Rome Foundation has established positive diagnostic criteria that are well accepted in the field.

Biopsychosocial model

An approach which proposes that illness and disease result from simultaneously interacting systems at the cellular, tissue, organismal, interpersonal, and environmental level. It incorporates the biologic aspects of the disorder with the unique psychosocial features of the individual, and helps explain the variability in symptom expression among individuals having the same biologic condition.

  • When diagnostic studies were negative, it was presumed that the patient had a psychiatric problem. This relates to a misunderstanding of the nature of disease and illness called dualism: "If the studies are negative then the symptoms must be in her head." It is more appropriate to understand this from the Biopsychosocial model of illness and disease. (Learn more by viewing this video of Dr. Drossman discussing doctor-patient communication.)
  • Once the diagnosis was made the patient had a miraculous cure to the treatment. I think we can all identify with this young athlete whose life was put on hold as she had to suffer with this disabling condition. But the article leads us to believe that her biofeedback treatment led to dramatic cure. I believe there is some poetic license taken here to lead us to this satisfying ending. Yes, the pelvic floor dyssynergia does respond to anorectal biofeedback, but the abdominal distension is a more complex physiological entity and should not respond to that. Patients with functional GI disorders must often deal with a lifelong history of symptom relapses and remissions or must try to control constant symptoms every day. This is the reality. While we can hope for cure which occurs with some patients, the majority need to accept FGIDs as a chronic disorder. But much like migraine headaches and arthritis, there are treatments that can reduce symptoms intensity and improve quality of life.

I’m sure this type of article may lead many patients to physicians who will do more and more studies to rule out "organic" disease in the hopes of achieving a cure. As physicians and patients are so afflicted, we need to understand that diagnosis and treatments are at hand once we give up a few misconceptions.

For a link to the New York Times article and to read Dr. Drossman’s full post, as well as the articles referenced in Dr. Drossman’s article, visit: http://drossmancenter.com/misunderstood-functional-gi-disorders/.

Dr. Drossman currently sees patients at his practice, Drossman Gastroenterology, in Chapel Hill, North Carolina. You can learn more about his practice at www.drossmangastroenterology.com.

Advocacy News
Health Policy
Budget & Appropriations
Legislative Agenda
Medical Nutrition Legislation
COVID-19 Legislative Updates
Medical and Treatment News
Industry Treatment News
Medical News
Medical News - Archive (2006-2013)
Advocacy Events
Professional Meetings
Patient Education
Norton Education Series
NES Education Program
NES Program Speakers
Press Releases
2020-Gastroparesis: Quality of Life and Symptom Burdens for Patients
2020-IFFGD Announces the 2020 Research Recognition Award Winners
2020-IFFGD's IBS Patients' Illness Experience and Unmet Needs Survey
2020-IBS: More Questions Than Answers?
2020-IFFGD Raises Awareness for Rare Digestive Diseases on Rare Disease Day
2019-IFFGD recognizes December as Constipation Awareness Month with the launch of Animated Patient’s Guide to Constipation
2019-IFFGD Shares GI developments with #GivingTuesday
2019-IFFGD Celebrates 20 Years of Raising GERD Awareness
2019-IFFGD Raises Awareness for Gastroparesis Awareness Month to Encourage “Education”
2019-0516 IFFGD Announces 2019 Research Recognition Awards Recipients
2019-0328 IFFGD Encourages Patients to Share "What I Wish People Understood About My IBS" for IBS Awareness Month
2018-1205 IFFGD Marks Constipation Awareness Month with Launch of Education Campaign
2019-0213 IFFGD Sheds a Light on the Daily Impact of Rare Digestive Disorders for Rare Disease Day 2019
2018- 1107 IFFGD Celebrates #GivingTuesday
2018-1101 Have You Heard? It Could Be GERD!
2018-0801 IFFGD Raises Awareness for Gastroparesis Awareness Month to “Make Patient Voices Heard”
2018-0529 IFFGD Presents 2018 Research Recognition Awards at DDW
2018-0402 Social Taboos, Lack of Awareness May Prevent Diagnosis & Treatment of IBS
2018-0212 IFFGD Raises Awareness for Rare Disease Day 2018
2017-1114 Holiday Heartburn or Something More?
2017-0802 Research Survey Reveals Unmet Needs of People with Gastroparesis
2017-0403 IFFGD Encourages People to See Their Doctor for Symptoms of IBS
2016-1115 GERD is More Than Simple Heartburn
2016-0801 Learn the Facts About Gastroparesis
2016-0405 Think You Have IBS? Find Out For Sure Before Starting a Treatment
2015-1123 Is it More than Simple Heartburn? Ask Your Doctor.
2015-7-30 Gastroparesis is a Hidden Medical Condition for Many
2015-0330 Online Survey Looks to Help Improve Outcomes for those with IBS
2014-1119 Persistent Heartburn May Be a Sign of GERD
2014-0826 Lack of Awareness of Gastroparesis May Impact Medical Care
2014-0326 IFFGD Marks IBS Awareness Month with Launch of Mobile App
2014-0225 IFFGD Research Grants to Study Gastroparesis
2013-1106 15 Tips for GERD Awareness Week
2013-0626 New DHA.org
2013-0412 IFFGD Presents 2013 Research Awards
2013-0401 Turning Attention to Returning Vets
2012-1109 Banish Frequent Heartburn by Burning More Calories
2012-0321 April is IBS Awareness Month: A Serious Issue for Veterans
2011-1130 Is Your Child's Reflux/Spitting Up A Point of Concern?
2011-0412 IFFGD Research Award Winners
2011-0329 IBS Signs You Should Not Ignore
2010-1118 GERD Difference
2010-1001 Heartburn or GERD?
2010-0517 US House Resolution for IBS
2009-1109 GERD at Night
2009-0417 IFFGD Research Award Recipients
2008-0331 Dealing with Digestive Disorders
2007-1118 When Is Simple Heartburn Not So Simple?
2007-0718 Proposed FDA Funding Applauded
2007-0401 IBS Myths
2006-1116 GERD & Holidays
2006-0418 Natl Commission
2006-0321 Women's Health
2006-0202 IBS or Something Else
2005-1125 GERD Costs
2005-0412 IBS Awareness
2004-1125 Heartburn & Heartache
2004-0929 Norton Honored
2004-0525 IBS Travel Tips
2004-0408 IBS Medical Care
2004-0101 IFFGD Conference
2003-1117 GERD Treatment
2003-0401 IFFGD Research Awards
2003-0401 IBS Awareness
2002-0423 IBS-C Treatment
2002-1102 Heartburn Caution
2002-0402 IBS & Lost Potential
2002-0423 IBS in Real World
2001-1119 Heartburn or Heart Attack
2001-0322 Patients First
1998-0401 IBS Millions Suffer
1997-1114 Research & Women's Health
Misunderstood Functional GI Disorders
IBS is No Joking Matter
For Media
Reporters' Guides
Media Contact Form